Back to Blog

Software Engineering

Fixed Price vs Time and Materials: Which Contract Suits Your Software Project?

Fixed price suits software work with a clear, stable scope. Time and materials suits work where the scope will change. Many projects use both: fix the price of a short discovery or first release, then move to time and materials.

Azhar Ali Dar

Software Developer

November 3, 20268 min read

Fixed price vs time and materials comes down to one question: how stable is your scope? Fixed price suits software work with a clear, stable scope: you know the cost up front, but every change costs extra. Time and materials suits work where the scope will change: you pay for the time spent and can re-prioritise freely, but you have to manage the budget. Many projects use both, fixing a first release and then moving to time and materials.

Many comparisons of fixed price vs time and materials are written for accounting, construction or general project management. This one is for UK businesses buying software: how each model behaves once the project starts, the hybrid models in between, and what the contract needs to say whichever you choose. It doesn’t quote prices, because the model you choose doesn’t decide the price of the work. It decides who carries the risk when estimates are wrong.

What is a fixed-price software contract?

The supplier agrees to deliver a defined scope for an agreed price, usually paid in milestones. If the work takes longer than estimated, the supplier absorbs the cost. If you want something the specification doesn’t include, it becomes a change request, priced separately.

It works well when:

  • the scope can be written down precisely, for example a rebuild of an existing system with known features
  • the work is short enough that requirements won’t drift before it’s finished
  • you need a firm figure for a budget approval or a funding round

Its weak point is the specification. Every ambiguity becomes a negotiation: was that feature “in scope”? Suppliers protect themselves by adding a margin for risk and by writing tight specifications, so a fixed price can cost more than the same work on time and materials, even when nothing changes.

What is a time and materials contract?

You pay for the time the team actually spends, at agreed day or hourly rates, plus any agreed expenses or third-party costs. Scope is managed as a prioritised backlog: you decide what the team works on next, and you can change your mind as you learn.

It works well when:

  • you’re building something new and expect to learn from users as you go, as with a minimum viable product
  • the work is ongoing: new features, maintenance, a long-running product team
  • you want to stop or change direction without renegotiating a contract

Its weak point is budget control. Nothing in the model stops the bill growing, so you need visibility: regular demos, time reports, and a forecast of what’s left against what’s been spent.

Which is cheaper, fixed price or time and materials?

Neither model is cheaper in itself. The same work costs what it costs; the model decides who pays when the estimate is wrong.

Fixed price Time and materials
Who carries estimate risk The supplier (priced into the quote) You
Cost of changing your mind A change request each time Re-prioritise the backlog
Budget certainty High, for the agreed scope Lower, unless capped
Effort needed from you Mostly up front: a detailed specification Ongoing: prioritising, reviewing, deciding
Best when Scope is known and stable Scope will change, or the work is ongoing

As a rule of thumb, fixed price tends to cost more when the scope is clear (you pay for the supplier’s risk margin) and much more when it isn’t (you pay for change requests). Time and materials tends to cost less when the team is good and you prioritise well, and more when nobody is watching the budget.

When should you choose each?

Work through these questions:

  1. Could you write the scope down today, in enough detail to test against? If yes, fixed price is realistic. If not, you’ll either pay for a specification first or end up in change requests.
  2. How long is the work? The longer it runs, the more likely requirements are to change. Fixed price suits weeks or a few months more than a year-long programme.
  3. How much of your own time can you give? Time and materials needs someone on your side who can prioritise and make decisions every week or two.
  4. Is the budget fixed? If the budget is truly fixed, a capped time and materials contract often protects you better than a fixed price, because you choose what to cut.

What about hybrid or capped models?

Many software contracts combine the two:

  • Fixed-price discovery, then time and materials. A short, fixed-price phase produces the scope, designs, technical approach and an estimate. You then build on time and materials, or take a fixed quote for the first release with far less guesswork in it.
  • Capped time and materials. Time and materials up to an agreed maximum for a defined piece of work. You keep flexibility, the supplier can’t run over silently, and you decide what happens if the cap is reached.
  • Fixed price per release or sprint. The first release is fixed; each later phase is quoted separately once the previous one is live.
  • A dedicated team for a monthly fee. Common with software outsourcing to India and other long-running work: you pay for a team’s capacity and direct its priorities, which is time and materials in all but name.

We usually recommend starting with a short, fixed-price discovery. It’s the cheapest way to find out whether a fixed price for the build is even sensible.

What should the contract say either way?

The pricing model is one clause. These matter just as much:

  • Scope and acceptance criteria. What “done” means for each deliverable, how you test it, and how long you have to accept or reject it. Vague acceptance terms leave room for disputes whichever pricing model you use.
  • Change control. How changes are requested, estimated and approved in writing before work starts.
  • Intellectual property. GOV.UK says that if someone is self-employed, they usually own the intellectual property even if you commissioned the work, unless the contract gives you the rights. Transferring copyright needs a written, signed document. The contract should assign the code, designs and documentation to your company once paid.
  • Accounts and access. The code repository, hosting, domains and app store accounts should be in your company’s name from the start, so you can change supplier.
  • Payment terms. Milestones for fixed price; invoicing frequency, time reporting and any cap for time and materials.
  • Warranty and support. How long the supplier fixes defects at no cost after acceptance, and what ongoing support costs.
  • Data protection. If the supplier handles personal data, UK GDPR requires a written contract with a processor, with the terms set out in Article 28.
  • Exit. Notice periods, handover of code and documentation, and what happens to work in progress.

If you engage individual contractors who work through their own limited companies, rather than an agency or development company, check the off-payroll working rules (IR35). The client decides the contractor’s employment status, unless the client is a small business outside the public sector.

Choosing the model for your project

If you have a clear, stable specification and a short timeline, ask for a fixed price, and read the change control clause carefully. If you’re building something new, or the work will run for months, use time and materials with a cap, regular demos and a budget forecast. If you’re not sure which you’re in, pay for a short discovery first.

We work both ways on bespoke software projects, and the contract always assigns the code to you. If you’d like an honest view on which model fits your project, tell us what you’re planning.

Frequently asked questions

Is a fixed-price contract less risky?

It moves the risk of the agreed work taking longer onto the supplier, which is why fixed quotes include a margin for it. It doesn't remove the risk of building the wrong thing. If the scope turns out to be wrong, you pay for changes on top of the fixed price, so a fixed price is only as safe as the specification behind it.

What is a capped time and materials contract?

You pay for the time spent, as with time and materials, but up to an agreed maximum for a defined piece of work. If the work is finished under the cap you pay less. If it would go over, the supplier has to stop and agree with you whether to cut scope, raise the cap or absorb the difference, depending on the contract.

Who owns the code under each model?

The pricing model doesn't decide ownership; the contract does. GOV.UK says a self-employed person usually owns what they create even when you commissioned it, unless the contract gives you the rights, and work done by employees usually belongs to their employer: with an agency, that's the agency, not you. Make sure the contract assigns the intellectual property in the code and designs to your company, in writing.

What is change control?

An agreed process for handling changes to scope: who can request a change, how the supplier estimates its effect on cost and timeline, and who approves it, in writing, before work starts. It matters most on fixed-price work, where every change outside the specification changes the price.

Can we switch models mid-project?

Yes, if the contract allows it. A common pattern is a fixed-price discovery or first release followed by time and materials for ongoing work. Agree the switch point and the rates in advance, so it isn't renegotiated under pressure.

About the author

Software Developer

Azhar Ali Dar works on custom software engineering at CyberSpark and handles Employer of Record and statutory compliance solutions at EOR Services (https://www.eor-services.co.uk/), writing about distributed teams, payroll and UK employment law.

Continue reading

Related Articles

Explore additional perspectives related to this topic and expand your implementation strategy.

Want to talk this through?

Tell us about your project and a person on our team will reply with practical next steps.

Contact us